Follow Dallas Linkedin
Email Dallas Email
Financial
Aug 7, 2019

Fairness and Equity Among Family Members

Sponsored Content provided by Dallas Romanowski - Managing Partner, Cornerstone Business Advisors

If you’re like many business owners, your business plays a large role in supporting your family’s lifestyle. As you plan for your business’ future, you may run into questions about how to treat family members fairly in your plans. This is especially crucial if you have children who work in the business and children who do not work in the business.

When planning for your business’ future success, you will likely need to address how you will eventually distribute your assets to children or close family members. As you address this issue, you may realize that what you consider fair is quite different from what your children and family consider fair. Consider the story of owner Bill Budster.

Bill Budster was 70 years old and ready to transfer his business. Two of his stepchildren, Beau and Donna, had worked in the business for 20 and 15 years, respectively. His other three biological children — George, Gary, and Heath — had successful careers outside of the business. Bill had always planned to transfer ownership to his stepchildren, but his plans ran into some problems.

Bill’s business was valued at $8 million, more than enough to provide his family members with financial security. Over the next four or five years, Bill wanted to split ownership in the business evenly between his stepchildren using a discounted value to account for the sweat equity they’d put in. Since they began working in the business, cash flow had risen steadily while they earned somewhat modest salaries, and Bill didn’t think it would be fair to make them pay full value.

But when Bill’s biological children learned about his plans, they argued. Bill had planned to provide $500,000 to each of his biological children upon his death, which he believed was more than fair. His children, on the other hand, wanted to know why each stepsibling would receive about eight times more than what each biological child would get, based on what the business was worth. They also wanted to know why their stepsiblings, who weren’t blood related, would reap financial benefits now, while they would have to wait until after Bill died to reap theirs.

Bill wasn’t sure what to do. When he asked his stepchildren whether they would be more interested in receiving cash after his death instead of business ownership, they declined. They’d worked hard in the business. Each had continuously turned down higher-paying offers to work in the business. They both had ownership mind-sets.

Despite weeks of discussions with his children, Bill realized that neither side would budge on what they wanted or considered fair. His stepchildren were upset that Bill had considered rescinding ownership after years of telling them he intended to transfer the business to them. His biological children felt that receiving cash after his death wasn’t enough and that they should receive equal value as their stepsiblings, at the same time.

Bill began to wonder whether he should simply sell the business to an outsider, but his stepchildren said they would not work in the business for anyone other than Bill or themselves. And if they left the business, Bill knew his cash flow and business value would crash. He felt stuck.

What Can Bill Do?

Bill’s biggest mistake was confusing equality for fairness. His biological children believed that fairness meant they would get equal shares of assets as their stepsiblings. His stepchildren believed that fairness meant recognizing their hard work and following through on his promises.

Rather than trying to negotiate with his children directly, Bill could have given them an objective rundown of his plans. He may have explained to everyone that the value of the business wasn’t liquid and that Beau and Donna would need to continue performing well to truly reap the benefits of ownership. He could have showed his biological children the tax consequences of ownership and the fact that Beau and Donna had effectively paid for their shares of ownership through working hard and foregoing other opportunities. In short, he could have communicated that his stepchildren’s shares of assets were loaded with risk, whereas his children’s portions of the family wealth were much less risky.

Likewise, Bill could have created incentive plans for his stepchildren in earlier years that recognized their contributions and rewarded them with ownership. Beau and Donna both said they would leave the company if they didn’t receive the ownership Bill promised them. This backed Bill into a corner, because if they ever left the business, his company wouldn’t see strong growth, which would make the business far less valuable, especially to any potential outside buyers.

When planning for your business’ future as it relates to your family, communication and fairness — not necessarily equality — are key. You don’t have to communicate and consider what’s fair alone. If you’d like to discuss how you can treat your family as fairly as possible as you plan for your business’ future, please contact us today.

© Copyright 2019 Business Enterprise Institute, Inc. All Rights Reserved

As a member of the Business Enterprise Institute (BEI), Cornerstone Business Advisors is an authorized distributor of BEI’s content and Exit Planning Tools.

The Cornerstone team includes former C-Level executives, successful entrepreneurs and advisers who offer unmatched experience in delivering advanced, custom-tailored, results-oriented solutions for business leaders. As a member of the Business Enterprise Institute (BEI), Cornerstone is an authorized distributor of BEI’s content and Exit Planning Tools. We developed the Performance Culture System™ to help clients implement best practices and drive high performance throughout their organization. For more information, visit www.launchgrowexit.com, call (910) 681-1420 or email [email protected]

Other Posts from Dallas Romanowski

Bizjournalblockad
Ico insights

INSIGHTS

SPONSORS' CONTENT
Connorkeller headshot

Patience Pays Dividends

Connor Keller - Live Oak Private Wealth
Girardnewkirk headshot 2182174430

Entrepreneurship Drives Social Elevation

Girard Newkirk - Genesis Block
Aaeaaqaaaaaaaaidaaaajdhiztrkodm0lte2yjetngrkmy1hotrmltawmdvlmwqyztmymw

With (More Than) A Little Help from Our Friends

Diane Durance - UNCW Center for Innovation and Entrepreneurship

Trending News

Atlanta-based Developer Plans More Than 300 Apartments In Leland

Cece Nunn - May 7, 2021

Local Business Leaders Weigh In On Brunswick's MSA Future

Christina Haley O'Neal - May 6, 2021

Vantaca Fills HOA Industry Need

Scott Nunn - May 7, 2021

Meet The 2021 CEA Winners

Vicky Janowski - May 7, 2021

General Aviation Services Business Hiring Ahead Of Busy Season

Christina Haley O'Neal - May 7, 2021

In The Current Issue

Vaccination 'passports' Come Into Focus

CastleBranch, the Wilmington-based consumer reporting agency, touts its status as “one of the first companies in the world” to issue a COVID...


Gym App Does Some Of The Lifting

President and founder Albert Steed explained that the app came from years of working in software development while actively engaging in vari...


Wilson Center Springs Back To Life

More than a year after closing its doors to the public due to a worldwide pandemic, Cape Fear Community College’s Wilson Center welcomed gue...

Book On Business

The 2021 WilmingtonBiz: Book on Business is an annual publication showcasing the Wilmington region as a center of business.

Order Your Copy Today!


Galleries

Videos

Trying to Grow a Business?
2020 Health Care Heroes
2020 WilmingtonBiz 100