Print
Restaurants

Midtown Incredible Pizza Changes Hands

By Jamie Lynn Miller, posted Nov 3, 2021
Jay Askew has been a professional pie guy for more than two decades. From Chicago-style deep dish to pepperoni rolls from Pittsburgh, the new co-owner of Midtown Incredible Pizza brings Italian food-savvy from some of the nation’s hot spots.
 
“I’ve done a lot of pizza makin’ in my life,” said the 22-year Wilmington local.
 
And he’s managed Italian restaurants, too, from Papa Gino’s in Boston to Antonio’s in Wilmington. Midtown Incredible Pizza is the first place to call his own.
 
The location’s name is changing to Jay’s Incredible Pizza.
 
They serve it up in-house, online, take-out and delivery, and the menu keeps growing: an amalgamation of good Italian from Askew’s culinary travels. Staples include tiramisu cups, cannoli rolls, salads, calzones, Stromboli – and of course, that Chicago-Style pizza.
 
Though the name may change (stay tuned: Jay’s Incredible Pizza), pepperoni rolls from Pittsburgh are here to stay.
 
Co-owner Tom Hayes owns Myrtle Grove Inn and drives a school bus.
 
“Now he’s flippin’ pies with me,” Askew said with a laugh.
 
With a tried-and-true location at 3600 S. College Road, Suite A and an established following, the new owners of Midtown Incredible Pizza tip their hat to former owner Andrew Kelly, who helped build the customer base.
 
The restaurant currently has dinner hours 4 p.m.-9 p.m. and plans to add lunchtime hours soon.
 
“Incredible Pizza has been around here for about 10 years,” Askew said, “and we’re the last location!”
Ico insights

INSIGHTS

SPONSORS' CONTENT
Elizabethredenbaughheadshot300x300

Strong Families Build Strong Communities—and a Stronger Workforce

Elizabeth Redenbaugh - Coastal Horizons
Untitleddesign12 101424113223

The Real Impact of Working On Your Business, Not In It

John Monahan - Vistage
Kelley tyler natural1

Why the Best Time to Save Money on a Building Is Before Anyone Breaks Ground

Tyler Kelley - Samet Corporation

Trending News

YMCA Dives Into Project Bringing Olympic-sized Swimming Lanes To Market Street

Cece Nunn - Nov 16, 2026

Institutional Investors Enter Local Industrial Market In Recent Deals

Emma Dill - Nov 16, 2026

In The Current Issue

New Restaurant Channels Greek Isles

​“Celebrate the madness of being alive” is the slogan for Opa by Giorgios, 14 Harnett St. The new restaurant aims to transport customers to...


Health Care Heroes: Nurse

This category honors a nurse whose performance is considered exemplary by patients, peers and other healthcare providers....


Heroic Moments In Healthcare

The nominations for this year’s award finalists highlighted heroic moments, from small but important moments to community-changing deeds....

Book On Business

The 2026 WilmingtonBiz: Book on Business is an annual publication showcasing the Wilmington region as a center of business.

Order Your Copy Today!


Galleries

Videos

2024 Power Breakfast: The Next Season