Print
Real Estate - Residential

Echo Farms Lawsuit Settled; Golf Course To Close This Fall

By Cece Nunn, posted Sep 15, 2017
Residents of Echo Farms and the owners of the Echo Farms golf course have settled a lawsuit over redevelopment of the golf course. (File photo)
A U.S. District Court judge signed off Thursday on a settlement agreement between Echo Farms residents and the owner of the Echo Farms golf course in Wilmington.

The agreement ends a court case that began after residents learned of Matrix Development Group's plans to close the golf course and use the land to create a single-family, townhome and multi-family development called The Woodlands at Echo Farms.

The settlement does not involve any money but does involve concessions made by golf course owner Matrix Development Group. While some of the settlement details remained confidential Friday, concessions included an increase in some of the buffers between The Woodlands and existing neighborhoods and homes, modifications to the overall design of The Woodlands, and Matrix's plans to keep the existing pool at Echo Farms Golf & Country Club open through next summer, said Joe Taylor, CEO of Matrix Development Group. 

The golf course will close sometime this fall, Taylor said.

"What we've accomplished here on the settlement agreement has been the fruit of a lot of efforts between EFRA [the Echo Farms Residents Association] and the individual litigants and Matrix, which together with all the discussions and all negotiations with Save Echo Farms have really combined to make it a better community going forward," Taylor said of The Woodlands.

The residents' group Save Echo Farms, which has been pushing for the local officials to buy some of the golf course property for a public park, was not part of the court case against Matrix. The Echo Farms Residents Association and individual homeowners filed suit last year to try to halt the development, citing restrictive covenants that they believed should still apply.

The case was moved from New Hanover County Superior Court to U.S. District Court, Eastern District of North Carolina, at the request of Matrix Development. The dispute went into mediation in June, and on Thursday, a consent judgment and settlement agreement were signed by Chief U.S. District Judge James C. Dever III.

Echo Farms dates back to 1974, when 207 lots were recorded for the original Echo Farms subdivision, and a Matrix company, Echo Farms LLC, has owned it since 1998, according to the consent judgment. The judgment said any restrictions in place at that time constitute personal covenants, "enforceable only between the original covenanting parties (Echo Farms Joint Venture and Echo Farms Golf and Country Club, Inc.), they do not run with the land and are not enforceable as to Echo Farms LLC or its successors in title to the Property (or the Adjacent Property)."

"When we went to the mediation period, it was made clear to us at the beginning that we could not negotiate saving the golf course; that was out of the question, and we decided to continue with the negotiations because we just ran out of money," said Henry Winters, an Echo Farms resident and EFRA member who was involved in the case.

Winters called the pending loss of the golf course "a hard pill to swallow."  He said four of his neighbors on Foxhall Court in Echo Farms have put their homes up for sale.

But Winters also said that during mediation, Matrix officials "were very nice, nice in their negotiation, and they wanted to bend over backwards where they could in their development activities to please us as neighbors to get the best possible development." 

He said 95 percent of the golf course's trees will be saved.

For The Woodlands at Echo Farms, engineering work is expected to be complete before the end of this year, while the permitting and approval process is anticipated to extend well into 2018, Taylor said.

Correction: This version corrects the spelling of Chief U.S. District Judge James C. Dever III's name.

Story On The Map

Ico insights

INSIGHTS

SPONSORS' CONTENT
Dave hoff heashot 300x300

Individual Assessments: People Decisions Driven by Science

Dave Hoff - EASI Consult
Leath 683x10242

Make People Plans for 2019

Lisa Leath - Leath HR Group
Lgoriginalheadshot 311794626

Summer is the New Holidaze

Laura Bransfield - Summerfield Custom Wellness

Trending News

Pender County To Get Another Distribution Firm

Christina Haley O'Neal - Dec 13, 2018

Why This House Coming To Marsdon Avenue Is Unique

Cece Nunn - Dec 14, 2018

Info Junkie: Chandler Hatch

Staff Reports - Dec 14, 2018

Recruiters Talk Challenges In Hiring And Retaining Tech Talent

Johanna Cano - Dec 12, 2018

Supplying This Year's Oyster Season

Jessica Maurer - Dec 14, 2018

In The Current Issue

Supplying This Year's Oyster Season

Like many oyster farmers in the area, Conor MacNair had to contend with damage from Hurricane Florence as well as customer perceptions about...


Cape Fear Museum Gets Smithsonian Affiliation

Cape Fear Museum of History and Science has received a coveted designation. The museum is now one of only seven organizations in the state t...


Top Stories No. 10: Changes In Local Retail Landscape

2018 Year in Review: Good times and bad times hit Wilmington’s retail scene this year....

Book On Business

The 2018 WilmingtonBiz: Book on Business is an annual publication showcasing the Wilmington region as a center of business.

Order Your Copy Today!


Galleries

Videos

2018 Power Breakfast - Dishing on the Restaurant Biz
2018 WilmingtonBiz Expo - Keynote Lunch with Eric Dinenberg, Rouse Properties
2017 Health Care Heroes