Print
Health Care

NHRMC Receives C Safety Grade Amid Data Lag

By Cierra Noffke, posted About 7 hours ago
For fall 2026, Novant Health's New Hanover Regional Medical Center received a C safety grade from Leapfrog, a nonprofit watchdog organization. (File photo).

Novant Health New Hanover Regional Medical Center (NHRMC) received a C hospital safety grade from The Leapfrog Group, a national watchdog nonprofit, in its fall 2026 cycle. Leadership at Novant Health NHRMC and Leapfrog say a reporting delay led to the use of outdated metrics in the grade. 

Leapfrog releases twice-yearly hospital safety grades using a combination of data from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) and voluntary surveys. The grades, released in the spring and fall, measure a hospital’s ability to protect patients from medical errors, accidents, injuries and infections, according to a Leapfrog press release. 

While Leapfrog surveys collect current data for each grade cycle, CMS data can lag by a year or more. 

According to Leah Binder, president and CEO of Leapfrog, the CMS measures that were not updated for this grade cycle were three patient safety measures Leapfrog identifies as “never events” on its website, or “events that should never occur,” which include retained foreign objects after surgery, falls and trauma and air embolisms. CMS would normally update those measures every August, Binder said. 

“Those updates are delayed, so we’re still using the data that was there as of last August,” she said. Data collected from July 2022 through June 2024 were used in the most recent grade for metrics on "safety problems" and "problems with surgery," which include patient falls, dangerous objects retained after surgery and death from serious treatable complications.

According to Laurie Whalin, president of the Novant Health Coastal Region, this most recent grade is the third in a row using the same “never-events” data that dates back to 2022. Whalin said more current data should reflect the hospital’s improvements, but Binder said it’s difficult to say for sure whether updated CMS data would have improved NHRMC’s grade, because hospitals are graded in comparison to other hospitals. 

“According to them, they’ve been improving, and the CMS update will show improvements, which I’m very pleased to hear,” said Binder. “And we certainly will welcome updating them in the spring with this new data. We were extremely disappointed that CMS delayed this implementation.”

CMS did not immediately respond to requests for comment as of press time. 

Another CMS measure not included in this cycle’s report was staff responsiveness, as CMS has paused public reporting of it. In response, Leapfrog increased the weight of nurse communication for the fall 2026 cycle, though it expects to include staff responsiveness in 2027, according to its website. 

Additional measures in NHRMC’s fall 2026 grade include declines in scores in nurse and doctor communication, with both scoring just below the national average. Scores for communication about medicines and discharge information improved. 

NHRMC’s score for central line infections improved, though urinary tract infections worsened slightly; both remain below the national average. Surgical site infections for colon surgery improved, though it is below average. The hospital’s MRSA infection score worsened slightly, though it remains just above average. Additionally, the hospital has made significant improvements over time in reducing C. diff infections; its score improved significantly in the cycle and is above average.  

Heather Davis, chief clinical officer of the Novant Health Coastal Region, said that while individual measures can vary, over the last two years, the hospital has seen a “continuous improvement trend” in infection and patient-safety categories. She also said the hospital was holding provider engagement sessions across specialties and units, focused on engagement and morale.

Novant Health acquired the previously county-owned hospital in a sale finalized in 2021. Whalin has acknowledged the difficult years the hospital experienced shortly after the transition. During the COVID-19 pandemic, the hospital faced significant challenges, such as a heavy reliance on travel nurses to address workforce shortages. In 2022, CMS threatened to terminate NHRMC’s Medicare contract following an inspection of the facility.

“There were some rough years in here,” Whalin said. “And some of those worst years were 2021, 2022 and 2023.”

Novant Health NHRMC’s hospital safety grade fell from a B to a C in fall 2024, though Whalin and Davis emphasize that the hospital has since made gains. 

“In the past 18 months to two years, we’ve been on a journey that has really shown significant improvement,” Whalin said. 

She added, “When those start to catch up to the 2025, 2026, and beyond actual date range, you will see that significant improvement in the scores.”

In May, CMS upgraded the hospital to three stars, citing improvements in mortality, safety of care and timely and effective care. Additionally, in September, Vizient, a provider-driven healthcare performance improvement company, ranked NHRMC at No. 3 out of 89 participating pediatric hospitals.

Binder said that Novant Health, as a whole, performs very well, and she is optimistic about NHRMC's ability to improve its safety grade score, pointing out that Novant Health leadership is “very candid about reporting how they’re doing, good, bad and ugly. They’re very transparent, and that’s a good sign.”

“What we generally see from the system is very high performance, and they seem to set high standards,” she said. 

Binder added, “I really do have a lot of confidence that we’ll see improvement from any hospital that has the Novant name attached to it.”

Novant Health’s Brunswick Medical Center received an A in the most recent cycle, its fourth consecutive A grade since the spring of 2025. 

Binder also cautioned that Leapfrog’s safety grade shouldn’t be the only metric patients use to evaluate a hospital, adding that it's important to check hospital websites for performance data and talk directly with hospital staff. 

“We believe that the safety grade should be your first stop in researching hospitals,” she said, “but certainly not your only stop.”

Novant Health submitted a proposal to the state in June to build a 225-bed heart and vascular tower on NHRMC's campus, in response to the State Medical Facilities Plan, which identified a need for 225 acute care beds in New Hanover County. Atrium Health and UNC Health also submitted competing proposals for proposed community hospitals. 

The state is expected to decide on the three proposals by late November or early December.

Ico insights

INSIGHTS

SPONSORS' CONTENT
Whalinheadshot11

Building the Right Kind of Capacity for a Growing Region

Laurie Whalin - Novant Health
Kelley tyler natural1

Why the Best Time to Save Money on a Building Is Before Anyone Breaks Ground

Tyler Kelley - Samet Corporation
David glew 207202 21

Back to Business: Cameron School of Business Begins a Bold New Year

David Glew - UNCW Cameron School of Business

Trending News

YMCA Dives Into Project Bringing Olympic-sized Swimming Lanes To Market Street

Cece Nunn - Nov 16, 2026

Institutional Investors Enter Local Industrial Market In Recent Deals

Emma Dill - Nov 16, 2026

In The Current Issue

Industrial Spaces Look To Grow

“A lot of companies look for existing buildings when they’re looking for new locations to expand or relocate,” an economic development leade...


Coastal Horizons Chief Finds New Purpose

The Coastal Horizons Center president and CEO is scheduled to accept the lifetime achievement honor Nov. 12 during an awards ceremony at UNC...


Riverlights Continues To Grow Housing

The 1,400-acre Riverlights master-planned community on River Road in Wilmington welcomed its first residents in 2016. Since then, the commun...

Book On Business

The 2026 WilmingtonBiz: Book on Business is an annual publication showcasing the Wilmington region as a center of business.

Order Your Copy Today!


Galleries

Videos

2024 Power Breakfast: The Next Season