Real Estate - Residential

Selling Iconic Property On Iconic Island

By Cece Nunn, posted Jun 21, 2019
The home at 49 Pipers Neck Road on Figure Eight Island recently sold for $4.8 million. (Photo c/o Landmark Sotheby's International Realty)
More than 30 years later, Buzzy Northen and his wife, Ellen Northen, are still in love with Figure Eight Island.
“It’s just heaven,” Buzzy Northen said as he sat in the Figure Eight Island Yacht Club’s dining room at lunchtime in June.
The Northens purchased a lot on the nearly 5-mile private island in 1986. Figure Eight, a thin, pristine barrier island just north of Wrightsville Beach, has no condos, no duplexes, no apartments and no commercial development.
It’s been home or vacation destination to celebrities, politicians and tycoons of various industries.
And no one is allowed across the island’s private bridge except property owners and their guests or vacationers with passes.
When the Northens first discovered Figure Eight through friends of theirs, Buzzy was a stock broker in Richmond, Virginia. Seven years ago, the couple moved here to sell real estate on Figure Eight under the umbrella of Intracoastal Realty.
The rest, as they say, is real estate history, one that’s been marked by healthy real estate careers for the couple.
“People ask what’s been the secret of our success,” Buzzy Northen said. “The true secret of our success is that we’re so passionate about being here and it’s where we live. Our children grew up here and grandchildren. This is where they want to be.”
Recently, they were involved as buyers’ agents in what was, as of press time, the most expensive luxury residential real estate sale of the year.
In a $4.8 million deal, the home at 49 Pipers Neck Road was purchased by Louise F. Brady and her husband, James E. Brady, of Greensboro, according to the deed dated May 21. The seller was 49 Pipers Neck LLC.
The 6,588-square-foot home located on a private peninsula and surrounded on three sides by water was listed by Nick Phillips of Wilmington- based Landmark Sotheby’s International Realty.
The home was built by Jim Farlow in 2000 for James “Chip” Mahan III, CEO and chairman of Live Oak Bancshares, and his family, and the Mahans sold it in 2005.
“Basically Mahan said, ‘Here’s the best lot on all of Figure Eight; let’s build something special on it,’” Northen said Friday.
Phillips said, “That house is really an iconic property on the island.”
He said the waterfront estate was designed by mid-century modern architect Ligon Flynn.
“I believe that house was really one of his finest works,” Phillips said.
The listing stated, “The property boasts four pavilions and multi-level outdoor living areas with gorgeous sound and ocean views that never end. Fantastic details throughout this entertainer’s dream include custom reclaimed cypress siding from the Cape Fear River, vaulted ceilings, oak hardwood floors, and indoor-outdoor sound system and elevator.”
The home was listed by Landmark Sotheby’s for $5.2 million and last sold during the pre-recession market of 2005 for $5.25 million, according to the N.C. Regional Multiple Listing Service and property tax records. The N.C. Regional MLS shows that the May 21 transaction is the highest- valued residential closed sale in the region so far, said Kathleen Baylies, broker in charge of Wilmington- based Just For Buyers Realty.
“It actually was under contract its first day on the market,” Phillips said. “It was such a spectacular property, truly one-of-a-kind.”
Buzzy Northen said Figure Eight Island’s success can be attributed to a number of factors, with defining moments including Hurricane Fran in 1996 and the establishment of Eagle Point Golf Club nearby on the mainland in the year 2000. After Fran, which was a Category 3 major hurricane, the damaged island showed resiliency with its survival.
Then, four years later, “the opening of a world class golf course here in Wilmington, a private course, the prestige of it, everything about it, and the fact that you had a private island a mile away just changed the perception. . . It brought in a whole new group of clients.”
The impact of Hurricane Florence is still evident in some cases, with tarps on roofs and workmen busy still completing repairs on the island. But it hasn’t seemed to slow interest, said Ellen Northen.
“We’re still recovering from the hurricane, but we’ve never been so busy,” she said.
Kirra Sutton of Figure Eight Realty said, “The market on Figure Eight has been very strong for the past several years.”
Figure Eight Realty is located on the island with an office in the yacht club’s facilities. Judy Parlatore is the broker in charge, and the agency also includes JoEl Skipper, Sutton said.
She said she keeps a close eye on the island’s home sales, which can number between 20 and 30 each year in stable and strong markets, via the N.C. Regional Multiple Listing Service and her own spreadsheet.
“There are certain locations and price points that we have limited inventory for, so that has been a bit of a price driver in those locations, but overall, the market has been very strong,” she said.
Soundfront and oceanfront lots are coveted, Realtors said.
The Northens said oceanfront lots alone can cost $2.5 million. Soundfront lots with docks can cost $2.6 million on average, but none were for sale as of press time.
The number of sales this year so far (8 as of June 13) is a little bit lower than the 13 that had sold as of June last year. But two or three other sales are pending, Sutton said.
“So we’re on target,” she said. Buzzy Northen said, “It’s just slowly being discovered because there’s nothing else like it anywhere near here."
Ico insights


Lyleheadshot2017 1251720228

What to Expect When You are Expecting A Hurricane

JC Lyle - Wilmington Area Rebuilding Ministry
Jim ellis headshot 10311631058

5 Tips for Tradeshow and Conference Videos

Jim Ellis - Signal

Roof Maxx is a Roofing Disrupter

Christy West - Roof Rescue of Wilmington LLC/Roof Maxx

Trending News

River Place Developer Proposes $90M Downtown Gateway Project

Christina Haley O'Neal - Sep 19, 2019

Embattled Country Club Aims To Continue Operating After Bankruptcy Filing

Johanna Cano - Sep 20, 2019

Building Leased To NHRMC Sells For More Than $5.8M

Cece Nunn - Sep 19, 2019

Banking On History

Jenny Callison - Sep 20, 2019

Downtown Apartment Units On The Rise

Cece Nunn - Sep 20, 2019

In The Current Issue

Banking On History

Historic landmarks, like a chapel that people are working to save in the northern Brunswick County town of Navassa, can help build an area's...

Startup Automates Workflow

A Wilmington company has developed a cloud-based application for small businesses that manages client information, invoicing, documents, ema...

One Chef, 3 Restaurants At Roudabush

Farm-to-table expert and San Francisco transplant Erin Wiley is the executive chef at not one but three of downtown Wilmington’s most freque...

Book On Business

The 2019 WilmingtonBiz: Book on Business is an annual publication showcasing the Wilmington region as a center of business.

Order Your Copy Today!



August 26, 2019 Power Breakfast: A Healthy Sale?
WILMA's Leadership Accelerator
2019 WilmingtonBiz Expo Keynote Lunch - CEO, nCino, Pierre Naude`