The interviews have begun.
Earlier this month, hospital, county and community representatives involved with exploring New Hanover Regional Medical Center made their short list for detailed talks.
Of the six health systems that submitted proposals for buying or partnering with NHRMC, three moved ahead of the rest of the pack for further due diligence, with potentially a multi-billion deal at the end for the county-owned hospital.
Atrium Health, Duke Health and Novant Health came up as the top picks for several of the groups involved in the process.
The Partnership Advisory Group, NHRMC trustees and county commissioners all voted unanimously at their respective meetings in recent weeks to move those proposals to the front.
The other three proposals – from HCA Healthcare, HealthSpan and UNC Health – are not technically off the table, officials said. That’s in part because a public hearing about the submissions required under state law has not been able to take place yet with the ban on large gatherings during the COVID-19 situation.
County commissioners Monday approved holding that hearing on June 22.
Also not off the table, according to Partnership Advisory Group leaders, are the scenarios of not making a deal with an outside health system by keeping NHRMC like it is now as well as restructuring its model internally to get around some of the limitations they say it has as a county-owned facility.
“Every decision we make is balanced against status quo, internal restructuring – every step of the way,” said Spence Broadhurst, co-chair of the Partnership Advisory Group (PAG), which is made up of 21 members. “As we move forward with any further recommendation, we will continue that analysis.”
With the recent votes, due diligence talks are taking place with the three health systems as well as site visits, both virtual and in-person with small groups. PAG members will ultimately recommend to county commissioners and hospital trustees what direction they think should be taken and whether to negotiate a letter of intent with one of the systems. Since the PAG is an advisory group, the final decisions rest with the county commissioners and hospital trustees.
PAG members have been evaluating the proposals on 18 issues, from expanding and reconfiguring facilities to health equity programs to local control. The group’s scoring on how the health systems’ proposals did in responding to those 18 areas are not being released. But here is a closer look at some of the areas being evaluated.
Atrium Health: A long-term lease of the hospital – over 40 years before it would become owner, with a pledge to spend $3.1 billion on New Hanover Regional Medical Center and the community. That includes upfront money to the county, lease payments and capital project investments, including a behavioral health and addiction treatment facility.
“We make sure we’re meeting the needs of the local community, and so this lease will allow us to do that,” said Ken Haynes, greater Charlotte region president for Charlotte-based Atrium Health. “We’ve heard the community say loud and clear, ‘[We] don’t want necessarily sell the hospital or be in a position where we go forward with a partner that may not work.’”
Duke Health: Said it is open to discussing different partnership models; In the case of a purchase it proposed to either pay $500 million and let New Hanover County keep NHRMC’s net cash – estimated at $440.5 million before the COVID-19 pandemic’s financial strain – as well as fund the hospital’s $1.9 billion 12-year capital plan. Or, alternatively, it proposed an acquisition offer of $1.35-$1.4 billion for an all-cash closing, with the county still keeping the net cash but the spending commitment for capital projects being $400 million for the five years after the deal closes.
The first option “is a capital commitment upfront with a long-term funding of a capital plan as we understood it from the New Hanover [Regional Medical Center] leadership,” said William Fulkerson, Durham-based Duke University Health System’s executive vice president.
“That creates a certain amount of money that goes to the county short term, but it maintains a long-term commitment on the part of the health system to achieve that vision," said Fulkerson, a physician and Duke University School of Medicine professor. "The destination medical center is going to require investment, is going to require capital; it’s going to require more technology. And that proposal recognizes that and also recognizes the plan that’s been developed by the leadership.”
Note: The plan Fulkerson referred to is NHRMC’s long-term strategic plan the health systems were asked about commitments to funding for the routine maintenance needs and capital projects. That strategic plan has not been made public for competitive reasons, and officials said the responding health systems accessed high-level versions of it.
Novant Health: Also said it is open to various models besides acquisition; proposed up to $2 billion in upfront cash proceeds to New Hanover County for buying the hospital and $50 million to the NHRMC Foundation, irrespective of the structure. It also pledged to fund the capital needs in NHRMC’s strategic plan under an acquisition to $3.1 billion or a significant percentage under another type of deal.
“We feel there is the potential care … for the coastal community with New Hanover Regional Medical Center as a flagship and [Novant Health] Brunswick [Medical Center] – they’re in collaboration and working alongside,” said Pam Oliver, executive vice president of Winston-Salem-based Novant Health.
“It would be similar to what we have currently in our Charlotte market with a flagship hospital and multiple other facilities that are driving care more locally and in the area," added Oliver, a physician who is also president of Novant Health's medical group
Atrium Health: Atrium pointed out that since 2009 it has managed NHRMC’s physician practices and employs most of the providers in the group, which has grown from 23 physicians in 2009 to 207 now in 39 locations. In its proposal, Atrium said it would continue to grow the network and address urgent care and convenient care focuses. “We also will focus on developing larger/multi-specialty medical office buildings … that can accommodate multiple practices in one location,” the proposal stated. “Finally, we will expand our established virtual primary care platform to include NHRMC and its entire service area,” which covers seven counties in the region.
Duke Health: Duke’s system already has been implementing its own ambulatory and network expansion plan, with nearly 600 additional providers and about 20 new sites. “This commitment to growth will extend to NHRMC, supported by Duke’s financial commitment and alleviating NHRMC’s limitation to fund growth outside New Hanover County,” stated the proposal, which describes the potential for NHRMC as “regional destination medical center.”
Note: One of the limitations hospital officials have pointed to with NHRMC’s current structure is that it cannot use bond financing to build outside of the county.
Novant Health: Novant also said it has been investing heavily in its ambulatory footprint, including outpatient surgery centers, imaging centers and urgent and express care facilities. “We have reviewed [NHRMC’s] strategic master plan and are aligned in terms of the emphasis on multifaceted ambulatory growth which includes expansion of the primary care network, expansion of the Scotts Hill Medical Campus, development of freestanding emergency departments and other initiatives in the near term and beyond,” Novant’s proposal stated.
Note: NHRMC is the region’s largest employer with about 7,500 workers.
Atrium Health: Last year, Atrium spent over $19 million to increase wages for more than 15,000 nurses and nursing support staff. (NHRMC last year also spent nearly $12 million in market adjustments for more than 4,100 employees and also raised its minimum pay threshold to $12.50 an hour.) “In keeping with our track record of maintaining and growing the local employment base when we partner with a local provider, Atrium Health will maintain the current NHRMC employment base and over time grow the enterprise and thus grow local employment,” its proposal stated.
Duke Health: Duke’s proposal recognized that NHRMC has been highlighted as a top employer, ranking 131st nationally on Forbes’ list of America’s Best Large Employers last year. “Duke commits to retain all NHRMC employees in good standing for a period of at least 12 months following the transaction close,” its proposal stated. “In addition, NHRMC compensation and benefits will be substantially similar for a period of at least 12 months following the transaction close and will remain market-competitive in the future.”
Novant Health: Novant said that under a partnership there would be no changes to employment levels without approval from the NHRMC board and that the hospital’s senior leadership team would remain in place, “with increased responsibility for an expanded regional network including Novant Health Brunswick Medical Center.” Additionally, there would be an increase in jobs in the county “by establishing a new shared services center and basing a corporate department in Wilmington,” the proposal stated.
“For all of our partnerships, [we] leverage what it is from a shared services perspective that we can do to drive value and decrease the overhead and the cost that takes away from what we can do at the clinical area,” Oliver said. “If we can decrease corporate overhead, decrease expenses and instead put that into patient care, then that optimizes the benefit in the community.”
June 4 and 18: The Partnership Advisory Group continues to meet every other week. The virtual meetings are open to the public to listen through a phone line or online through Webex. Meeting access and agenda details are listed on nhrmcfuture.org under the PAG tab.
Upcoming meetings are slated to focus on reviewing the initial site visit findings, evaluating the partnership options in comparison to status quo and internal restructuring options, and discussing the finalists’ presentations.
Portions of the meeting might be held in closed session.
June 15: PAG leaders are slated to give an update to county commissioners on the progress of the due diligence and letters of intent with the three organizations.
June 18: The Business Journal hosts a virtual Power Breakfast on the topic of the hospital’s future with PAG co-chairs Barb Biehner and Spence Broadhurst; New Hanover County Manager Chris Coudriet; and NHRMC President and CEO John Gizdic.
Reader questions can be submitted during the livestreamed discussion, 8-9:30 a.m., or emailed ahead of time to [email protected]. Info: WilmingtonPowerBreakfast.com
June 22: New Hanover County commissioners hold a public hearing on all six proposals. Details on time and place have not yet been announced.
July, possibly: If the PAG sticks to its schedule, members are looking to vote in July on their recommendation for whether to keep the hospital as is, restructure or their top pick for an outside partner during its July meetings.
Watch the Business Journal’s BizTalk video interviews with executives from the three health systems:
Cece Nunn - Sep 17, 2020
Cece Nunn - Sep 16, 2020
Jenny Callison - Sep 15, 2020
Christina Haley O'Neal - Sep 15, 2020
Christina Haley O'Neal - Sep 15, 2020
Small businesses affected by the COVID-19-related economic downturn have much to think about for the remainder of this calendar year. So say...
Numbers have always held an allure for Tammika Brown, and eventually, they added up to a career for her....
“I think in some ways, it was a blessing because even though I was in clinical research and I had been a nurse, breast cancer gave me a pat...